This Coin Owes Its Origins to the 3 Cent Stamp

Posted on Leave a comment

In 1851, a U.S. postage stamp cost 3 cents.

America was growing fast at this time and the California Gold Rush prompted the development of new U.S. gold coins.

The Mint Act of February 21, 1853 authorized a $3 gold coin.

The $3 gold coin matched up with an existing 3 cent silver piece, which was already heralded as a convenient coin for Americans to buy stamps.

Numismatics widely assume that the $3 gold piece was created so people could quickly and easily buy a sheet of 100 first class stamps. The beautiful $3 Indian Princess gold coin is an exquisite example of the close connection between postal and coinage history in our country.

Yet even today there remain questions about the $3 gold coin.

One industry expert wrote that “whether or not the $3 denomination was actually necessary or worthwhile has been a matter of debate among numismatists for well over a century.” Despite the mystery around the $3 coin, it remains a highly sought and hard to find gold coin.

Numismatics began collecting the intriguing $3 Indian Princess gold coin as early as 1879. The entire series produced from 1854-1889 saw so many low mintage dates that the entire series is considered rare. The highest mintage of any $3 gold coin was a tiny 138,618. Many were lost to the melting pot in the 1930’s, which reduces the number of survivors available today. 

Many consider the $3 Indian Princess the most beautiful gold coin struck in the 19th century. Designed by the U.S. Mint’s chief engraver, James B. Longacre, the $3 gold coin was the first time he had been given the freedom to create a design of his own imagination.

Longacre wrote that previous to the $3 gold coin, he had been directed to adapt Roman or Greek features into U.S. coins. For the $3 gold coin, Longacre was determined to create something uniquely American.

“From the copper shores of Lake Superior to the silver mountains of Potosi, from the Ojibwa to the Araucanian, the feathered tiara is a characteristic of the primitiveness of our hemisphere as the turban is of the Asiatic,” Longacre wrote.

He was inspired to feature an “Indian Princess” on the obverse of this stunning coin. A lustrous orange-gold color, the coin shows a gorgeous Indian Princess adorned with a feathered headdress, with the words UNITED STATES OF AMERICA circling her. On the reverse, the date and denomination is surrounded by an agricultural wreath celebrating corn, tobacco, cotton, and wheat.

Blanchard currently has just one excellent specimen of the 1854 $3 Indian Princess PCGS MS64 CAC, which is the only year to feature the word DOLLARS in small letters on the reverse.

In 1855, the world DOLLARS was enlarged, amid complaints from the public.

This $3 gold coin boasts excellent eye appeal and is great example of the type.

The Story of Benjamin Franklin’s Libertas Americana Coin

Posted on Leave a comment

It was October of 1781. US forces had recently defeated the British in Yorktown. The win was a turning point in the Revolutionary War. Though it would be nearly two more years until the US claimed victory, many were beginning to see how the war would end bringing a close to more than 8 years of bloody battle.Libertas Americana Medal

Ben Franklin was in Paris when he learned the news of the US victory in Yorktown. Thrilled by the message, Franklin drafted a response stating, “this puts me in mind of a medal I have had in mind to strike since the last great event…” That other great event was the crucial US victory in Saratoga in October 1777. It was a violent battle in which 440 British troops died and nearly 100 American troops lost their lives. In the end, more than 6,000 British troops were captured during the fighting. Benjamin Franklin’s Libertas Americana coin would be an effort to permanently commemorate these two pivotal moments in history.

The Libertas coin, however, would serve as more than a reminder of the Americans’ bravery in the Revolutionary War.  It would also pay respect to the French. Franklin wanted to draw attention to French support and the resources they offered which were indispensable in the American’s effort to win the war. Their help likely shortened the length of the Revolutionary War. As the American envoy to the court of Louis XVI, Ben Franklin was keenly aware of the power of such a steadfast ally.

Ben Franklin turned to renowned engraver Augustin Dupré to design the piece. His association with the project was fitting not only because of his talents as an artist but because he started his career as an engraver in France at the royal factory for weapons and therefore had experience creating images commemorating war and victory on the battlefield.

Dupré designed one side to show the profile of the head of Liberty with the words Libertas Americana circling around the edge. Below the profile is the date, July 4, 1776 commemorating the Declaration of Independence. The reverse shows France as a soldier armed with a spear and holding a shield while defending America, depicted as an infant, from the British, depicted as a lion. The symbolism in the Libertas Americana coin is powerful as Dupré goes to great lengths to evoke the burgeoning nature of America’s independence amid threats from the British. In an arc around this image is Latin, which translated reads, “The brave infant is aided by the Gods.”

With Benjamin Franklin’s encouragement, minting officials completed the coin dies for striking by March of 1783.  He decided to issue the Libertas coin in three varieties, gold, silver, and copper. The largest portion of the coins struck was copper totaling approximately 200 pieces. The only two gold pieces struck were reserved for Louis XVI and Queen Marie Antoinette. The whereabouts of these two incredibly rare pieces is unknown, though many believe they were melted during the upheaval of the French Revolution. The US struck 50 silver pieces and distributed them to high-ranking government and military officials and European heads of state. These low counts make the coin exceedingly rare.

By the late 1950s renewed interest in the coins prompted the French mint to locate the long unused Libertas Americana dies. French officials found them, however, they were heavily corroded. It was not until 1975 when a private numismatic brokered a deal to have the Paris Mint issue restrikes in a larger size.

Today, the Libertas Americana coins are not only a reminder of the victories of the Revolutionary War, or France’s assistance, but of the influence of Dupré’s work. Since issuing the coin the head of liberty, as designed by Dupré, can be seen on later works like the 1792 pattern dime, the 1793 half cent and the 1793 Liberty Cap, and others.

Perhaps more than any other coin the Libertas Americana manages to touch on so many facets of the American identity.

What the End of Globalization Means for You

Posted on 1 Comment

Globalization gets a bad rap.

Just like much of economics, globalization is a zero-sum game.What the End of Globalization Means for You

There are Winners and Losers

American manufacturing workers were losers during the recent wave of globalization. It’s blamed for massive job loss here in America as manufacturers chased cheaper labor opportunities in other parts of the globe. To be fair, however, many economists point out that technology also contributed to the loss of manufacturing jobs.

American consumers won as our purchasing power increased with access to cheap imports, which included everything from sweaters to children’s toys to most items you’d pick up on a weekend shopping trip to Wal-Mart or Target.

The U.S. economy also won with a pick-up in economic growth since 1990. (Economic theory suggests that globalization is good for the world economy and economic growth and that seems to have played out during the recent globalization wave).

The stock market benefits from globalization as it opens borders, which allows higher corporate profits.

Over the past three decades, U.S. stocks outperformed equities elsewhere, Capital Economics notes.

“That in part reflects the success of US companies in harnessing globalization to increase their earnings in foreign markets and improve their margins by outsourcing their production,” Capital Economics said.

History Shows Waves of Globalization

Looking back over the past 150 years, there have been three distinct waves of globalization.

First Wave: 1870-1913

Second Wave: After WWII until the early 1970s

Third Wave: Around the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 and gained steam in the 1990s to the present.

Is the third wave ending now? Some economists say yes. And, the populist movement in America is pushing for that.

What’s at Stake

The current U.S. – China Trade war may have deeper implications for the future of global economic growth, U.S. economic growth and stock market returns.

Capital Economics released new research highlighting that “the de-globalization scenario that is most concerning is a deep split between a China- and US-led economic bloc. This could potentially lead to a permanent reduction in trend GDP growth.”

Capital Economics research shows that globalization has boosted asset returns over the past 30 years.

So, it makes sense if globalization halts that would weigh on stock market returns. Both bond and equity returns are likely to be lower over the next decade than in the recent past, Capital Economics said.

“If policymakers threw up major barriers to trade and sought to undo a significant part of global economic and financial integration, the absolute real returns from most assets would suffer and equities and industrial commodities would probably under-perform safe assets, such as high-grade government bonds and gold,” Capital Economics said.

The Bottom Line

The U.S. China Trade war encompasses many issues that are far-reaching to our future.

“If we are right that the trade war reflects China’s strategic threat to the US, then some form of decoupling is inevitable – which will have an adverse effect on global GDP.”

A major shift in the world economic order is underway. East is rising up against West. A breakdown of cooperation could have an impact on your portfolio and your wealth. Safe assets like gold are expected to outperform as the current wave of globalization comes to an end. Do you own enough?

Get our tales from the vault, our favorite stories from around the world and the latest tangible assets news delivered to your inbox weekly. Sign up for our newsletter!

Three Truths, And a Lie About Gold

Posted on Leave a comment

Investors sometimes hesitate when contemplating a gold purchase. They are unsure of about taking the next step because they find commodities confusing. This uncertainty is understandable. Gold is nebulous. It doesn’t trace back to a product, service, or a board of directors.Three Truths, And a Lie About Gold

In contrast, stocks and bonds are less opaque. They are the life blood of one of the most American of institutions: the corporation. People understand the basic idea of these two asset classes. With stocks you are becoming an owner of a company. With bonds you are becoming a lender to a company.

For too long, people have complicated gold investing by making false, or needlessly complex statements about the precious metal. Here, with the help of research from The World Gold Council, we dispel some of those myths by discussing the three key truths of gold, and one major misconception.

Truth: Gold is Less Volatile Than Other Commodities

Gold is more stable than a host of other commodities. The metal’s annual volatility is well below that of silver, platinum, and several commodity indexes like the Bloomberg Oil Index, the Bloomberg Energy Index, the Bloomberg Industrial Index, and even the S&P GS Commodity Index. Over the past 10 years, gold has been more stable than all of theses other commodities and indices.

Truth: Gold Delivers in High Inflation Environments

Between 1971 and 2018 gold has delivered an average annual nominal return of approximately 15% during periods of high inflation (>3%). What makes this performance so impressive is the fact that it outpaces the nominal average annual return of the Bloomberg Commodity Index over the same period. Even more impressive is the fact that in low inflation environments (<3%) gold still generates a positive return of approximately 5% while the commodities dip into negative territory.

Truth: Gold Behaves Differently Than Other Commodities

Gold is often discussed in investment literature as a commodity. While it is true that gold is a commodity, it is also misleading to discuss the precious metal as if it behaves like all commodities. Consider that gold tends to generate positive performance when volatility increases. For example, during the Great Recession, the Bloomberg Commodity Index lost more than a quarter of its value whereas gold delivered a return just shy of 50%. This same relationship occurred during the second Sovereign Debt Crisis in 2011 when the Commodity Index fell into negative return territory while gold delivered more than 25%.

Lie: Stocks Outperform Gold Over the Long Run

Of all the untrue statements about gold, this one is perhaps the most pervasive and harmful to investors. Over the past 20 years, gold has outperformed many different equity configurations including US stocks and EAFE stocks. In fact, gold has also outperformed the US Bond Aggregate, US cash, and the Bloomberg Commodity Index over the same period. Moreover, even when we extend this time line to the last 48 years we see that US stocks and EAFE stocks only narrowly outperform gold. It is also worth mentioning that this out-performance comes at the cost of increased volatility compared to gold.

Getting it right as an investor means getting the facts and nothing speaks louder, or truer, than data. Take these three truths (and this one lie) as a starting point to explore how gold really helps a portfolio over the long run.

Why Your Tangible Assets Portfolio Should Include Rare Coins

Posted on Leave a comment

It’s commonly know that gold is a great hedge against inflation and a proven portfolio diversifier.Why Your Tangible Assets Portfolio Should Include Rare Coins

What isn’t commonly known is that investments in U.S. rare coins do an even better job at growing your long-term investment returns.

In fact, the investment return on U.S. rare coins over the last 40 years is higher than other assets and TWICE THAT OF GOLD, according to an independent study by Raymond E. Lombra, Ph.D., entitled The Investment Performance of U.S. Rare Coins.

Current Environment Means Investors Need to be Proactive

Heading into the final quarter of 2019, we identify rising macro risks for investors. Here are just five of the risks that dominate the horizon as we cast our eyes into 2020.

  1. Liquidity Crisis: A cash crunch in the repo market starting in mid-September triggered a new round of quantitative easing by the Federal Reserve, through its daily injections of cash into the overnight market. The last time we saw actions like this? Right before the housing crash of 2007, which preceded the Great Recession.

  2. Negative Interest Rates: In a desperate attempt to stimulate economic growth, some developed countries have implemented so-called negative interest rates. Some central banks have turned to this untried “negative interest rate” policy method, which allows rates to fall below zero. Yes, that means you have to pay your bank to hold your savings. Countries that have, or had negative interest rates include the Euro area, Switzerland, Denmark, Sweden and Japan.

  3. U.S. – China Trade War: Recent economic data confirms that the trade war is beginning to slow U.S. and global economic growth.

  4. Stock Market Volatility: The 10-year old bull market in stocks is on its last legs. Increased volatility is a warning signal that a top could be forming now. In the first nine days of October, the S&P 500 registered four daily price swings of 1% or more.

  5. Trump Impeachment Inquiry: Political risks are rising with the Democratic impeachment inquiry and a presidential election in 2020.

Investment Recommendations for Third Quarter

We recommend investors take proactive steps to protect and grow wealth in the face of rising market uncertainty. There are simple steps you can easily take to play defense right now.

Past performance can give us clues about the future.

The appeal of rare coins is their impressive historical price appreciation, which has outpaced gold’s returns. Penn State University Professor Raymond Lombra conducted an independent study on the investment performance of U.S. rare coins from January 1979 to December 2016. He found that coins rated MS-65 nearly doubled the performance return of gold over that time.

  Average Annual % Returns
1979-2018
Stocks 12.4%
Treasury Bonds 7.7%
Gold Bullion 5.2%
Coins (all types – MS65) 10.3%
Coins (all types – MS63-65) 8.8%

Key Takeaway

That data shows if you converted a portion of your gold bullion holdings into rare coins you could double your investment returns on tangible assets over the next two to three years.

Digging into the data, rare coins and gold outperformed Treasury Bonds through numerous business and market cycles.

  • Dr. Lombra found that annual gold returns were positive in twelve of the past fifteen years.

  • Rare coin returns were positive in thirteen of the last fifteen years.

  • Lombra concluded that over the long run, including rare U.S. coins within an existing portfolio could improve investment performance.

Getting Started Is Easy

Take these steps now to reduce portfolio volatility and protect and grow your wealth during the next economic recession and bear market in stocks.

  1. Increase your overall exposure to tangible assets. Experts recommend up to 15-25% depending on your risk tolerance levels.

  2. Add exposure to U.S. rare coins at the MS65 level or better.

  3. Consider converting some of your current gold bullion holdings (likely at a nice profit) into rare coin holdings, which should outperform in the new gold bull market cycle that is just beginning now.

If the U.S. moves back to a zero-interest rate environment like it did during the 2009-2009 global financial crisis or even goes negative, or the stock market crashes, you can expect new all-time highs in gold above the $1,900 an ounce level. Many on Wall Street are already forecasting gold gains to the $2,000 an ounce level.

Just imagine what that will do to the U.S. rare coin market!

If history shows that U.S. rare coins gain twice as much as gold, investments in numismatics could easily double in 2020 and 2021 from current levels.

Incorporating defensive strategies like converting gold bullion into numismatics investments could be a way to more than double your investment return in tangible assets over the next two to three years. A Blanchard portfolio manager can help you develop a personalized investment plan when you call today at 1-800-880-4653.

 

What Does the Repo Market Drama Mean For You?

Posted on Leave a comment

Attention passengers, the pilot has turned on the seat belt sign. There is turbulence ahead. The latest drama in the repo market may be a wake-up call that all is not right in the banking system. What Does the Repo Market Drama Mean For You

The repo market, a little-talked about corner of the U.S. financial system has been making headlines in recent weeks. Even if you’ve never heard of the repo market before, this latest news could be a warning signal that the house of cards is about to crumble.

The repo market officially stands for the repurchase market. That is an overnight lending market where banks make short-term loans to each other.

Running short on cash for the day? Banks can borrow money in the overnight market and pay it back the next day, usually at a very low interest rate around the Fed’s benchmark rate of 1.75%-2.00%.

At least that is the way it is supposed to work.

In mid-September, repo rates surged to 10%. The party line is that big demand for cash came as U.S. companies were squeezed as they needed to pay their corporate tax bills, which drained available liquidity from the financial markets.

Wondering when the last time this happened? Yep, you guessed it. Right before the housing market crash in 2007 and the Great Recession that followed.

Buckle up those seat belts, the ride could get bumpy ahead.

The Federal Reserve stepped in as the lender of last resort and has pumped over $300 billion into the overnight lending markets in just one month since mid-September.

Compare that number to $800 billion – or the size of the Fed’s balance sheet before the 2008 Global Financial Crisis.

What’s happened over the last month is BIG.

Private financial markets need public support and the Fed is trying to be the knight on a white horse.

Can it work?

The Fed announced last week that it will purchase $60 billion of Treasury bills a month starting in October. This will continue “at least into the second quarter of next year” to maintain ample reserves. Only time will tell.

What’s really worrisome is that this is the first time in 10 years the Fed has intervened in the repo markets. What would happen if the Fed didn’t step in and lend to these banks? Another bank failure?

The bankruptcy filing of Lehman Brothers in September 2008 was the domino that triggered the Great Recession and a huge bear market in stocks.

When the stock market is churning out double digit gains it is all too easy to forget what happened 10 years ago.

During the last bear market in 2007-2009, the S&P 500 lost approximately 50% of its value.

That hurts.

If you haven’t fully protected your portfolio with tangible assets like gold, take action now before it is too late.

Average savings accounts at banks are about 0.05%.

You aren’t even keeping pace with inflation at that rate. Why keep your funds in a banking system that is already showing cracks at the edges. Or, why keep your funds fully invested in a stock market that could turn on a dime. We’ve had a great run in stocks, but the cycle is overdue for a drop.

The question to ask yourself now: do you want a guarantee that you’ll get your money back?

If yes, move your cash out of a banking system with little to no interest or out of the stock market that is just begging for an excuse to drop.

Get peace of mind with a safe haven investment in gold. You can trust your investment in tangible assets will hold and grow its value no matter what happens at the bank down the block or to the stock market next month.

The Tumultuous Times of the 1861 Indian Princess Gold Coin

Posted on 1 Comment

In the wild days of the California gold rush (1848-1855) the supply of gold surged in the US. This influx reinvigorated Congress’s interest in producing a gold coin dollar. Originally, the idea to issue a one-dollar gold coin came from Alexander Hamilton, the Secretary of the Treasury.1861 Indian Princess

For a long time, government officials, and the US public, advocated for such a coin. Their argument was that issuing a one-dollar gold coin would be convenient in lieu of higher denomination pieces already in circulation. The government made formal moves to make this happen with legislation calling for the minting process to begin. However, the provisions for the coin were removed from the Mint Act of 1837 leaving the initiative languishing. The $10 eagle gold coin was already in circulation and cited by some as a sufficient, existing alternative. However, the denomination didn’t suit everyone’s needs.

Despite this, concerns persisted. Some officials worried that a one-dollar gold coin would incite counterfeiting. Others warned that such a coin might cause confusion in the event that people mistook it for a similar sized half dime.

Eventually, the few dissenting voices faded, and the bill became law in March of 1849. Soon after, Chief Engraver James B. Longacre began his design. Originally the coin featured the head of Liberty surrounded by lettering reading “United States of America.” The same lettering appeared on the obverse with a “1” in the center surrounded by a wreath of olive branches. The composition was 90% gold, and 10% copper.

The original design became known as the “Type 1.” Later, the Type 2 was minted from 1854 to 1856. The reason for the redesign was pragmatic; the high relief design created problems at some of the mints. Longacre altered the head of Liberty and designed her as a Native American Princess wearing a headdress. Longacre also pushed the lettering on the obverse closer to the rim. Together these changes made the imagery sharper and improved the efficiency of the minting process solving the problems of the Type 2. This version of the coin was minted from 1859 to 1889.

However, as the Civil War drew near the volume of the coins minted began to fall. Originally the US minted approximately two million pieces per year. That number fell to about 50,000 per year by 1860. By 1861, when the Civil War began, the US only minted an estimated 1,000 gold dollar coins at Georgia’s Dahlonega mint. These pieces have a “D” marking to signify their origin.

These pieces are especially rare for several reasons. First, the dies used came from Philadelphia. Therefore, they had already experienced significant wear and were only used for a limited period before they cracked and were discarded. Second, those dies arrived in Georgia just days before the state decided to succeed from the Union. As a result, the state’s thinning resources meant that mining operations were likely limited. Third, by the second half of 1861 all dies and coins held at the mint in Dahlonega became property of the treasury of the Confederate States of America. Eventually, many of the 1861-D coins were melted.

Today, the pieces are coveted by collectors seeking to own a coin stamped during one of the most pivotal times in our history. In time the coin was abolished but its value endures.

Game of Thrones Coin: Mithradates VI Stater

Posted on Leave a comment

Well … almost. Here, see what we mean:

Matricide.

Fratricide.

Filicide.

The slaughter of an entire Roman province of 80,000.Kingdom Of Pontus Mithradates VI Stater

Who would do such things? Sounds like a villain out of Game of Thrones, right? Unfortunately, these acts are all too real. They were committed by King Mithridates IV, ruler of the Kingdom of Pontus.

Mithridates was loved by his people as their savior from Rome’s oppression. Rome, on the other hand, hated him as their most formidable enemy since Hannibal. For 26 glorious years, Mithridates evaded capture, immunized himself against poison by regularly consuming small doses, and won battle after battle against Rome.

His end came when his son led a rebellion against him and Pompey the Great defeated him in battle. But when Mithridates tried to commit suicide by drinking poison, his immunity worked … so he was killed by his foes instead.

You might not want to meet Mithridates in real life, but how does a coin from his rule sound? The coin’s reverse shows Athena sitting on a throne, while the obverse features a portrait of the deified Alexander, whose cloak Mithridates used to wear.

This gold stater dates from before the time of Christ: a true piece of antiquity to add to your collection now.

A Shipwreck for the Ages: The S.S. Central America

Posted on Leave a comment

The siren song of gold called from California to every corner of the country. Across the nation, men (and a much smaller number of women) sold their possessions, borrowed money, and spent their savings to get themselves to the Promised Land. The journey, however, was perilous. Prospective gold miners, called ’49ers for the year (1849) that the Gold Rush started, traveled overland across mountain ranges, sailed to Panama, and sailed around Cape Horn – all to reach California.

Just as dangerous in some ways was the trip from California to the East Coast. One ship that regularly made that journey was the S.S. Central America, a 280-foot, wooden-hulled steamer. Launched in 1853, the steamer operated continuously on the Atlantic leg of the San Francisco–New York Panama route.

In September 1857, the S.S. Central America, laden with passengers and 2 tons of gold and coins from San Francisco, sank in a hurricane off the coast of the Carolinas. 425 people perished, and the loss of the wealth contributed to the Panic of 1857, a depression felt around the world.

The Maritime Bounty is Discovered

For 131 years, the precious cargo lay nestled at the bottom of the sea, presumed lost forever. In 1988, a team using a remotely operated vehicle discovered the ship 160 miles off the coast at a depth of 7,200 feet. Gold estimated to be worth $100–150 million was recovered. Recovery lasted 4 years and covered about 5% of the shipwreck site.

The excitement didn’t stop there: The founder of the discovery company became embroiled in legal battles related to the shipwreck, and he and his assistant went on the lam in 2012. The fugitives were found by U.S. Marshals and extradited to Ohio in 2015.     

In 2014, a deep-ocean exploration firm began archaeological recovery of the ship. They discovered gold coins, nuggets, ingots, and dust. The coins included foreign gold and territorials as well as $20 Double Eagles, $10, $5, $2.50, and $1 gold coins. The coins date 1823–1857, with one scientist calling the hoard a “time capsule” of all coins in use in 1857.

Some standout coins from the S.S. Central America include $20 Liberty Double Eagle gold coins. The Liberty Double Eagle was authorized by Congress in response to the California Gold Rush, and was then minted for over 50 years. The obverse features a classic Greek Lady Liberty in profile wearing a crown bearing the word LIBERTY. The reverse shows a heraldic eagle holding a shield, an olive branch and arrows clutched in his talons.

In the first year, 1850, that the Liberty Double Eagle was minted, 1.1 million coins were produced. After that, far fewer were minted, and the Civil War also dramatically impacted their production. These coins are less frequently found than the Saint-Gaudens Double Eagles that replaced them in 1907.

Coins recovered from shipwrecks are renowned for several qualities. Firstly, they are rare. Of the thousands of ships that have sunk, few are recovered, and far fewer still have viable coins aboard. Secondly, shipwreck coins are rare historical artifacts, a glimpse into America’s past. And finally, many shipwreck coins have retained their details, luster, and full strikes, making them prized by collectors.

If you have a chance to get your hands on an S.S. Central America Liberty Double Eagle, consider it the opportunity of a lifetime. Life Magazine called the shipwreck’s bounty “…the greatest treasure ever found”.

If you’d like to read more about rare coins, market news and the latest on tangible assets, sign up for our newsletter!

Over 270 Million of These Coins Were Melted

Posted on 2 Comments

Over 270 million Morgan silver dollars met their fate in the melting pot under the provisions of the Pittman Act of 1918.  

The U.S. government ordered this dramatic move to save Great Britain from a banking collapse and may have also helped the Allies win the war.

How did this great silver meltdown come to pass?Morgan Dollars

Back then, international trade was conducted in gold.

Allies were buying steel, food and supplies to maintain their massive armies and paying in gold bullion. Gold became scarce. Hoarding was popular as the price was rising and exceeded face value of the coins. Great Britain resorted to silver certificates to pay for goods from India, its colony at the time, which was a major contributor to the war effort.

However, Great Britain had a silver problem. Germany began spreading rumors that Britain did not have enough silver to back the paper certificates it was using to buy war supplies, which many think was actually true!

Fortunately, for the war effort, America had a lot of silver dollars. At that time in the United States, of course, silver dollars could be redeemed by any citizen at any time for a silver certificate.

Senator Key Pittman of Nevada proposed legislation – the Pittman Act – and the United States came to the rescue. Passed on April 22, 1918, the Pittman Act authorized the melting of up to 350 million silver dollars – which could be sold to Britain for one dollar per ounce of bullion.

Millions of Morgan silver dollars were melted down in 1918 and shipped to England to avert crisis.

Britain honored its silver certificates and the U.S. silver sale helped prevent a banking collapse, riots in India over non-payment and helped keep the Allies flush with the money they needed to win the war.

Morgan silver dollars were first minted in 1878. The Morgan silver dollar was last minted in 1921 when it was replaced with the silver Peace dollar.

Collecting Morgans

Over 270 million Morgans are gone forever, lost to the melting pot. The dramatic history and significance of those remaining are what keeps collector interest high.

No good records were kept about which mintages were melted down, which has resulted in some surprises over the years.

Some of notable interest are Carson City Morgan silver dollars minted from 1880 through 1885. Why did so many survive? The answer is simple. When Carson City stopped producing coins, the Morgans were shipped back East and ended up in the back of the U.S. Treasury vault. During the great silver meltdown, coins were simply taken from the front and middle of the vault until no more were needed. The Carson City coins escaped melting pot since they were in the back of the vault!

Just getting started? Collectors often covet both the first and last year Morgan dollars – 1878 and 1921 – as they represent the beginning and end of this highly desirable coin series.

Do you have any Morgan silver dollars? Leave a comment below.

Want to read more? Sign up for our newsletter and get our tales from the vault, our favorite stories from around the world and the latest tangible assets news delivered to your inbox weekly.